Premierships and Grand Final Appearances

1921 1st XVIII Premiers – Carrum 7.17.59 d Hastings 7.4.46 – Played at Somerville
1932 1st XVIII Premiers – Carrum d Rosebud – Played at Dromana
1933 1st XVIII Runners Up – Rosebud 8.12.60 d Carrum 5.10.40 – Played at Dromana
1948 1st XVIII Premiers – Carrum 17.7.109 d Rye 14.14.98 – Played at Mornington
1955 1st XVIII Premiers – Carrum 6.13.49 d Rye 4.10.34 – Played at Dromana
1959 1st XVIII Premiers – Carrum 11.14.80 d Hastings 12.7.79 – Played at Mornington
1961 1st XVIII Runners Up – Frankston 12.15.87 d Carrum 9.14.68 – Played at Mornington
1963 2nd XVIII Premiers
1965 1st XVIII Runners Up – Edithvale Aspendale 11.6.72 d Carrum 8.13.61 – Played at Mornington
1966 3rd XVIII Premiers
1966 2nd XVIII Runners Up
1967 1st XVIII Runners Up – Chelsea 20.18.138 d Carrum 11.21.87 – Played at Mornington
1968 2nd XVIII Runners Up
1973 1st XVIII Premiers – Carrum 12.14.86 d Hastings 4.17.41 – Played at Mornington
1974 1st XVIII Premiers – Carrum 11.17.83 d Mornington 11.13.79 – Played at Mornington
1974 2nd XVIII Premiers
1974 3rd XVIII Runners Up
1975 1st XVIII Runners Up – Hastings 18.19.127 d Carrum 10.13.73 – Played at Mornington
1976 3rd XVIII Runners Up
1989 2nd XVIII Premiers
1993 1st XVIII Runners Up – Langwarrin 14.13.97 d Carrum 15.6.96 – Played at Frankston
1994 1st XVIII Premiers – Carrum 15.8.98 d Rosebud 13.8.86 – Played at Frankston
2013 2nd XVIII Runners Up – Doveton Eagles 11.15.81 d Carrum PL 7.5.47 – Played at Cheltenham
2013 1st XVIII Runners Up – Doveton Eagles 14.11.95 d Carrum PL 7.14.56 – Played at Cheltenham
2014 2nd XVIII Runners Up – Lyndale 16.10.106 d Carrum PL 5.9.39 – Played at Heatherton
2018 2nd XVIII Premiers – Carrum PL 7.7.49 d Frankston Dolphins 5.12.42 – Played at Keysborough
2023 2nd XVIII Runner up – Frankston Dolphins 14.12.96 d Carrum PL 9.8.62 – Played at Carrum Downs
2024 3rd XVIII Runner up – Heatherton 12.11.83 d Carrum PL 2.5.17 – Played at Mordialloc